International Convergence Of Chinese Accounting: Challenges And Opportunities

With the development of the global economy, thegovernment in economy activities becomes quite
pace of globalization has increased dramaticallynecessary. Otherwise, the newly published
within the past two decades.  To prevent thestandard could be in favor of those
risk of financial crisis, increase multinationalgovernment-controlled companies and become
business activities or reduce the cost, internationalobstacles for other companies to follow as the
convergence of accounting seems to be one ofresult of government controlling most capitals and
the most effective ways. For developednearly all major listed companies (Firth, 2006). 
countries, the accounting techniques have beenAnother concern is the lack of experiences and
adopted for a long time, therefore they alreadytrainings for Chinese accountants in making
have reached a high professional level. However,professional and ethical judgments. IFRS standard
for a developing country, such as China,allow companies to make their own judgments
convergence of IFRS (international Financialbased on economic substance of a company's
Reporting Standards) and local GAAP (Generallyactivities. However, most Chinese accountants
accepted accounting principles) are often seen asused to only follow the government rules and
a double-edged sword that brings bothwere rarely encouraged to perform judgment. 
opportunities and challenges.As a result, playing "number game" in order to
China's financial report practices can be tracedmeet the profit target could happen easily under
back more than 2000 years ago. Before 1800s,certain circumstance. Other concerns may include
China has its own primal accounting system andimmature policies, worries from Chinese
regulations developed from a Feudal society. Aftercompanies, etc.
the Sino-British Opium War in 1848, China beganAlthough China is facing challenges related to IFRS
its progress of importing the western accountingadoption, we still have many reasons to believe
system along with the western culture andthat the convergence of China's Financial
technology. Since the establishment of theReporting and IFRS could also bring great
People's Republic of China in 1949, China quicklyopportunities on China's economy growth in the
adopted the Soviet-type planned economy and itsfuture. First of all, China is now a member of
related accounting regulations and practices.World Trade Organization. The effective
However, from the 1978 reform, China'simplementation of IFRS in the country would
accounting system has undergoing a dramaticattract more foreign investments and enhance
change from a central rigid  account rule which isthe development of China's capital market. The
mainly assisting  the macro-economic planning forcompatibility between Chinese and International
the government, to a mixed system which isfinancial reports will greatly reduce the accounting
helping decision-making for both government andcost and increase the confidence for the foreign
investors. After 1992, with the development ofcreditors. Second, IFRS can help Chinese
economics and capital markets, China speed up itscompanies to improve their financial management
pace to harmonizes its accounting system withand decision planning by using a universal
international practices by declaring and applyingaccounting language. The companies' decision
more new accounting standards (Ding, 2008).makers would be provided more comprehensive
International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS)asset-liabilities reports instead of the old-style
is a set of accounting standards issued by thereports which may only focus on short-term
Board of the International Accounting Standardsbenefits. Third, IFRS would benefit China's external
Committee (IASC) after 2001.  Comparing totrade activities by providing Chinese with a
China GAAP, IFRS standards are more focus onpowerful weapon on dealing with trade fightings.
transparency of financial information andFor example, in the investigation of illegal dumping
substance of transaction other than uniformity ofcharges, a copy of clear and independent
practices. For example, In China's GAAP, Fixedaccounting book which follows international
assets should be capitalized only when it is relatedregulations would give solid anti-dumping evidence.
to operations of an enterprise with estimatedForth, unlike China GAAP, IFRS allow that the
service life of more than one year or when otherresearch and development expenses could be
fixed assets have a value over 2,000 RMBcapitalized. This could be an effective stimulant for
(approximately US $ 300) with service life ofChinese companies to promote product innovation
more than two years.  Unlike China GAAP,and technological upgrading, which used to be a
principle based IFRS allow judgment to exist whenrelatively weak point for developing countries.
applying the standards to a company's financials. China is holding his concept of 'Scientific
Companies could have their own professionalDeveloping' and having his own way of
judgment to determine a threshold above whichconvergence with IFRS. This way is rather unique
expenditure should be capitalized based onand quite different with United States or other
economic substance of a company's activities.countries. Chinese government is showing both
(Zhang, 2008)ambitions and cautions because the convergence
On October 29, 2009, China's Vice Finance Ministerprogress will have essential impacts on the China's
Li Yong said that the current Chinese Accountingeconomy in the future years.
Standards with International Financial Reporting 
Standards has achieved a substantial convergence 
through his "China Accounting and AuditingReferences:
Assessment Report".  Although China has made1. China Accounting Standards Committee. 2006.
more progress to convergence with IFRS, onlyChina Enterprise Accounting System (
selected companies are required to adopt these2. Firth, M. Fung, P., Rui,O., 2006. Corporate
new rules (China Accounting Standardsperformance and CEO compensation in China.
Committee, 2006). To successfully adjust the gapJournal of Corporate Finance 12, 693-714.
between local GAAP and IFRS, some practical3. Zhang, S., Lei, W. 2008 Analyzing Chinese
problems and obstacles need to be solved andFinancial Reporting. Beijing Review, February 28,
overcome. One of the problems is that Chinese2008
government is still playing a combined central role4. Ding, Y., Su, X., 2008. Implementation of IFRS in
in both economy policies and economy practice.a regulated market. J. Account. Public Policy.
Clarification on the role of Chinese central/local27:474-479.